Hotels near Sunset Beach Shelter Island Heights

Sunset Beach on Shelter Island Heights offers a range of hotel accommodations ideal for a relaxing getaway. Visitors can find charming beach hotels and luxury options with a variety of amenities, ensuring a comfortable stay. Many accommodations feature stunning views, pools, and fine dining, making it easy to unwind. Whether you prefer boutique hotels or spacious beach houses, the area provides options that cater to every traveler's needs, all while being close to the serene shoreline. These are some of the hotels preferred by our travelers near Sunset Beach:

1. The Pridwin HotelOpens in a new window: The Pridwin Hotel is a 3.0-star hotel located within a mile from Sunset Beach. This property is ideal for travelers seeking a beach, family, and spa themed vacation experience. Guests will enjoy direct access to the beach, making it a perfect spot for sunbathing and water activities. The hotel also provides a full spa with amenities like Body Wraps and Hydrotherapy Treatments. Families will appreciate the children’s amenities, including an Arcade Game Room and Pool Gate, ensuring a fun-filled stay for the little ones.
2. Shelter Island HouseOpens in a new window: Shelter Island House is a 3.5-star hotel situated within a mile from Sunset Beach. This property caters to families and golf enthusiasts alike, offering a unique Golf experience right on-site. Families can take advantage of the free crib service, making it convenient for those traveling with young children. The welcoming atmosphere and family-friendly amenities make it a great choice for those looking to relax and enjoy the beautiful surroundings of Shelter Island.
3. West Neck GuesthouseOpens in a new window: West Neck Guesthouse is another 3.5-star option located within a mile from Sunset Beach. This Bed & Breakfast-style lodging offers a delightful start to the day with free daily continental breakfast options. Guests can unwind with entertainment options such as a Flatscreen TV and Cable TV in the rooms. The cozy environment and complimentary meals make this hotel a wonderful choice for travelers looking for comfort and convenience during their stay.

A three-day getaway to Sunset Beach offers travelers stunning coastal scenery, pristine sands, and tranquil waters perfect for swimming and sunbathing. Enjoy leisurely boat rides, explore nearby forests, and unwind on the beach while soaking in breathtaking sunsets—an idyllic escape for relaxation and adventure. Here's a quick itinerary to make the most of your trip to Sunset Beach:

• Day 1: Begin your adventure at 67 Steps Beach, where you can enjoy the stunning views and relax by the shore. After soaking in the sun, make your way to the Camera Obscura, a fascinating optical device that offers a unique perspective of the surrounding landscapes. Conclude your day at Safe Harbor Stirling, a delightful spot where you can unwind with a delicious meal while overlooking the marina, perfect for watching the sunset.
• Day 2: Start your day at Crescent Beach, a beautiful location perfect for a morning stroll or a swim. Afterward, head to Sylvester Manor, a historic estate where you can explore its rich history and beautiful grounds. Wrap up the day at Havens House, a charming locale that provides insight into local heritage, allowing you to appreciate the culture and stories of Shelter Island.
• Day 3: Kick off your day at Sag Harbor Marine Park, where you can enjoy outdoor activities and stunning waterfront views. Next, travel to Orient Point County Park, which offers picturesque hiking trails and serene beaches. Finish your day at Mashomack Preserve, a natural sanctuary where you can hike through lush landscapes, spot wildlife, and immerse yourself in the tranquility of nature.

1. Book for the cheapest times: If you're looking for an affordable getaway, consider visiting Sunset Beach in January, November, or December, when hotel prices drop significantly. For the best experience, plan to stay for at least 2-3 days to fully enjoy the main attractions in the area, including the beautiful beach and scenic parks. This budget-friendly destination offers great value for money, making it perfect for travelers on a budget.
2. Look for last-minute deals on Hotels.com: If you’re looking for a relaxing getaway, last-minute deals to Sunset Beach can offer fantastic savings on cozy accommodations. To explore these offers on Hotels.com, head to the DealsOpens in a new window or Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window section, where you could find attractive discounts on nearby hotels as your travel date approaches. Additionally, consider enabling email alerts or push notifications from Hotels.com to keep informed about flash sales and exclusive last-minute promotions, so you’re more likely to snag a great deal for your Sunset Beach escape.
3. Be flexible with dates: Prices may fluctuate depending on factors like the hotel's location, star rating, and the time of year. As a result, if you can be flexible with your travel dates, you could save on hotel expenses near Sunset Beach.
4. Consider your location: When booking through Hotels.com for your holiday, keep your location in mind. Staying closer to major attractions or city centers can be convenient, but it often comes with a higher price tag. For more affordable options, consider hotels in areas that are usually a bit farther from the center, while still ensuring you can easily access the places you want to visit.
5. Upgrade with One Key: Make your next reservation near Sunset Beach and be a part of Hotels.com's free One Key program, which enables members to take advantage of reward points for hotel bookings. Progress through the tiers of Blue, Silver, Gold and Platinum to unlock advantages like room upgrades when available, discounted rates, and exclusive offers for members. Start earning reward points now.